Amanda Rogers...Human?

I think since Amanda Rogers lived her entire life as a human, she should have the 'human' trait as well as 'Q Continuum' trait. What do you guys think?
"When the Future becomes the past, the present will become unlocked."

Comments

  • Commander SinclairCommander Sinclair ✭✭✭✭✭
    There are TONS of examples to cite for adding the 'Human' trait BTW. I just figure we all already know which crew those are.
    "When the Future becomes the past, the present will become unlocked."
  • robownagerobownage ✭✭✭✭✭
    She definitely identified as Human, so I can see the value of adding it.
  • GhostStalkerGhostStalker ✭✭✭✭✭
    Surely, the whole crux of her episode was her fighting her Q nature with her desire to remain human.
  • PavelHPavelH ✭✭
    Considering Human is the most pointless trait it doesn't really matter.
  • Average GuyAverage Guy ✭✭✭✭
    Doesn't she stop being Human and become Q Continuum? Isn't that the whole point of the episode, that she isn't human any more?
  • Commander SinclairCommander Sinclair ✭✭✭✭✭
    Doesn't she stop being Human and become Q Continuum? Isn't that the whole point of the episode, that she isn't human any more?

    Regardless of the storyline, we have so many characters in this game that have multiples of traits that are questionable, but occur at some point in their storyline.

    TO be more on point for this character, I cite Human Q, who identifies as Q forever before the episode, then appears to be human for a few hours/days whatever, and he has both Human and Q Continuum traits.

    Amanda "identifies" as Human her entire life, then only "becomes" Q when her powers are unleashed by Q.
    "When the Future becomes the past, the present will become unlocked."
  • Average GuyAverage Guy ✭✭✭✭
    Doesn't she stop being Human and become Q Continuum? Isn't that the whole point of the episode, that she isn't human any more?

    Regardless of the storyline, we have so many characters in this game that have multiples of traits that are questionable, but occur at some point in their storyline.

    TO be more on point for this character, I cite Human Q, who identifies as Q forever before the episode, then appears to be human for a few hours/days whatever, and he has both Human and Q Continuum traits.

    Amanda "identifies" as Human her entire life, then only "becomes" Q when her powers are unleashed by Q.

    Excellent point, since he has both traits, it would make sense. The only other consideration would be the competitive nature of the traits in the game which DB manages. We can petition for the addition, but they will have to review it before changing.
  • Matt_DeckerMatt_Decker ✭✭✭✭✭
    Has anyone done an analysis of her Voyage totals?
    Fleet: Starship Trista
    Captain Level: 87
    VIP Level: 12
    Unique Crew Immortalized: 451
    Collections Completed: Vulcan, Ferengi, Borg, Romulan, Cardassian, Uncommon, Rare, Veteran, Common, Engineered, Physician, Innovator, Inspiring, Diplomat
  • Has anyone done an analysis of her Voyage totals?

    She's #82 on the voyage rankings, so fairly pedestrian in a vacuum. Other than the ENG/MED being flipped, she's not very different from Mirror Stamets. MED is a much better secondary to have, and she will play better than the raw numbers suggest.
  • robownagerobownage ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 14
    Yup, definitely a solid card. In addition to #82 Voyager (which undersells her value due to her SCI/MED/ENG combo, although DB has been playing nice and giving us a few options here lately), she's got the #4 base SCI and is #4 for the SCI/MED shuttle combo.
  • Synthetic CommanderSynthetic Commander ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited August 14
    robownage wrote: »
    Yup, definitely a solid card. In addition to #82 Voyager (which undersells her value due to her SCI/MED/ENG combo, although DB has been playing nice and giving us a few options here lately), she's got the #4 base SCI and is #4 for the SCI/MED shuttle combo.

    Except that base (shuttle) stats don't matter much with so few events. Her voyage total is barely above the keeper who's been around forever, with a similar event count. Personally I'd invest more in crew that would get more use and push voyages longer. Not many options for sci/med, but at least QOD will help there.

    Plus Keeper is in the portal already, while she won't be there forever. I like the art in this mega, but so far the crew have not been exciting besides the recurring.
  • robownagerobownage ✭✭✭✭✭
    robownage wrote: »
    Yup, definitely a solid card. In addition to #82 Voyager (which undersells her value due to her SCI/MED/ENG combo, although DB has been playing nice and giving us a few options here lately), she's got the #4 base SCI and is #4 for the SCI/MED shuttle combo.

    Except that base (shuttle) stats don't matter much with so few events. Her voyage total is barely above the keeper who's been around forever, with a similar event count. Personally I'd invest more in crew that would get more use and push voyages longer. Not many options for sci/med, but at least QOD will help there.

    Plus Keeper is in the portal already, while she won't be there forever. I like the art in this mega, but so far the crew have not been exciting besides the recurring.

    True for event potential, but she'll be a great B team when your main cast are tied up.
  • Should have human trait. Pretty simple. Agreed.
  • Mirror CartmanMirror Cartman ✭✭✭✭
    Traits are pot luck.

    Burnham does not have the Vulcan trait, and is as deserving as the human trait here.
  • (HGH)Apollo(HGH)Apollo ✭✭✭✭✭
    robownage wrote: »
    Yup, definitely a solid card. In addition to #82 Voyager (which undersells her value due to her SCI/MED/ENG combo, although DB has been playing nice and giving us a few options here lately), she's got the #4 base SCI and is #4 for the SCI/MED shuttle combo.

    Except that base (shuttle) stats don't matter much with so few events. Her voyage total is barely above the keeper who's been around forever, with a similar event count. Personally I'd invest more in crew that would get more use and push voyages longer. Not many options for sci/med, but at least QOD will help there.

    Plus Keeper is in the portal already, while she won't be there forever. I like the art in this mega, but so far the crew have not been exciting besides the recurring.

    She will be event crew for the next two events and quite possibly any Q events in the future. Keeper is a good card but he has not been an event crew in even one event and he is sci-med-com not sci-med-eng. Do many people even have the Keeper guy? I got him from a Tuesday pack. As with anything though, quality depends on what you already have. I am weak on sci-med and am happy to pair Amanda with Q as "God".
  • Dirk GundersonDirk Gunderson ✭✭✭✭✭
    robownage wrote: »
    Yup, definitely a solid card. In addition to #82 Voyager (which undersells her value due to her SCI/MED/ENG combo, although DB has been playing nice and giving us a few options here lately), she's got the #4 base SCI and is #4 for the SCI/MED shuttle combo.

    Except that base (shuttle) stats don't matter much with so few events. Her voyage total is barely above the keeper who's been around forever, with a similar event count. Personally I'd invest more in crew that would get more use and push voyages longer. Not many options for sci/med, but at least QOD will help there.

    Plus Keeper is in the portal already, while she won't be there forever. I like the art in this mega, but so far the crew have not been exciting besides the recurring.

    She will be event crew for the next two events and quite possibly any Q events in the future. Keeper is a good card but he has not been an event crew in even one event and he is sci-med-com not sci-med-eng. Do many people even have the Keeper guy? I got him from a Tuesday pack. As with anything though, quality depends on what you already have. I am weak on sci-med and am happy to pair Amanda with Q as "God".

    I immortalized my Keeper earlier this summer as my first true SCI/MED (or MED/SCI) legendary crew, shortly followed by the Mobile Doctor. The Keeper’s monster SCI proficiency, double 1000+ base skills, and rare skill combination have led to plenty of voyage use even when SCI and MED aren’t the two featured skills.

    Between those two, Qod, and Amanda, SCI/MED will have gone from a weakness two months ago to something I don’t have to really worry about anymore. And even though it’s a tertiary skill, Amanda’s ENG can only help even though I don’t feel all that terrible about my ENG/MED crew. Am I going to cite her immediately for that? I don’t think so, as I have a few other priorities first...but she’ll be closer to the top than the bottom.
  • Banjo1012Banjo1012 ✭✭✭✭✭
    robownage wrote: »
    Yup, definitely a solid card. In addition to #82 Voyager (which undersells her value due to her SCI/MED/ENG combo, although DB has been playing nice and giving us a few options here lately), she's got the #4 base SCI and is #4 for the SCI/MED shuttle combo.

    Except that base (shuttle) stats don't matter much with so few events. Her voyage total is barely above the keeper who's been around forever, with a similar event count. Personally I'd invest more in crew that would get more use and push voyages longer. Not many options for sci/med, but at least QOD will help there.

    Plus Keeper is in the portal already, while she won't be there forever. I like the art in this mega, but so far the crew have not been exciting besides the recurring.

    She will be event crew for the next two events and quite possibly any Q events in the future. Keeper is a good card but he has not been an event crew in even one event and he is sci-med-com not sci-med-eng. Do many people even have the Keeper guy? I got him from a Tuesday pack. As with anything though, quality depends on what you already have. I am weak on sci-med and am happy to pair Amanda with Q as "God".

    I immortalized my Keeper earlier this summer as my first true SCI/MED (or MED/SCI) legendary crew, shortly followed by the Mobile Doctor. The Keeper’s monster SCI proficiency, double 1000+ base skills, and rare skill combination have led to plenty of voyage use even when SCI and MED aren’t the two featured skills.

    Between those two, Qod, and Amanda, SCI/MED will have gone from a weakness two months ago to something I don’t have to really worry about anymore. And even though it’s a tertiary skill, Amanda’s ENG can only help even though I don’t feel all that terrible about my ENG/MED crew. Am I going to cite her immediately for that? I don’t think so, as I have a few other priorities first...but she’ll be closer to the top than the bottom.

    I’m going to DYC and cute her right up because I’ve been waiting for her for a very long time

  • Automaton_2000Automaton_2000 ✭✭✭✭
    Keeper is a good card but he has not been an event crew in even one event

    The Keeper has been bonus crew in six previous events, four of which were Factions or Faction hybrids.
    She will be event crew for the next two events and quite possibly any Q events in the future.

    I'm a bit pessimistic on future Continuum events; when they added the Q Continuum trait to the game, they also gave John de Lancie variants their own invisible trait, probably to differentiate him for future events. Who knows, though.
Sign In or Register to comment.